We ’ve heard a great deal of hype , on both sides , about the healthcare reform bill President Obama signalize today . But how will it really affect our future ? Here are five dystopias it may save us from , and one it could have .
Oh , and there are spoilers in this Wiley Post . learn out !
So the House of Representatives passed The White House / Congressional Leadership Reconciliation Bill ( H.R. 4872 ) on Sunday , and President Obama signed it today . ( There are still procedural hurdles in the Senate , but it ’s essentially a done slew , by all accounts . ) So now it ’s all over except for the court cases , jumbo raft of regulations , and the inevitable follow-up account . *
you’re able to read the whole schoolbook of the billhere , and there ’s a great compare with the previous House and Senate billshere ( PDF ) . So what does the bill actually do , in its final form , and how could it make our future more or less dystopian ? beaming you asked . Here are some dystopian scenarios that the bill makes less likely :
1 ) The mutant pestis .
An affluent country in which 30 million people only have accession to health care through emergency rooms and a few other source is a scary position . When such a huge fade of your universe is n’t getting basic screenings and preventive tending , it ’s like a welcome mat to eldritch disease .
It does n’t take much imagination to figure a scenario where a new epidemic sweep through the uninsured population , gaining too much grip for public wellness functionary to be able to cope with it by the time it attain the rest of the land . But even if you discount a 28 Days Later / I Am Legend * * type scenario , it get basic common sense that even people with wellness policy are salubrious if those who currently miss it get right treatment .
Under the bill that President Obama just signed into law , insurers will no longer be able-bodied to traverse anyone coverage ground on a preexisting precondition , or terminate coverage for existing customers using a procedure call “ recission . ” And there are no more lifespan limits on how many benefits you may receive . If your employer does n’t provide coverage for you ( or does n’t pay enough of the cost ) you ’ll be able to purchase insurance on a state - fly the coop “ exchange , ” where insurance firm vie to offer the best reporting at the lowest cost . And if your income is below a certain threshold , your indemnity premiums will be subsidized .
Also , there ’ll be no more “ doughnut hole , ” where Medicare drug reportage terminate after a sure monetary value story and then resumes after a “ catastrophic ” cost grade . Also , Medicaid doctor visit , include thing like immunization , will pay off at the same rate as Medicare , meaning doctor will suddenly be a lot more open to find out Medicaid patients for those things .
And the laweliminates Medicare cobalt - payments and deductiblesfor prophylactic service , and phases in a similar requirement for private health plans . Plushere ’s a middling good listof some of the other thing the bill will do to better preventive care and rural wellness care , among other things .
So how could meliorate access to health care services , and especially to preventive tending , help to stave in off the living dead apocalypse ? Well , it have in mind more of the population will be getting checkups , which means nasty disease are likelier to be entrance early on . Assistant Secretary of Health Howard K. Koh , MDsaysthat health care reform will have a net - electropositive effect on public health generally , because so many more people will have access to preventive fear and immunization . Koh cites a recent study saying 100,000 people die in the United States every class because of lack of access to basic preventative caution , like grippe shot .
So even if you already have great insurance , you”ll be healthier because other people will have it now . And you ’re less potential to be eaten by first-rate - pest - sport .
2 ) The fly middle socio-economic class , as company splits into the ruler and the undercity .
It ’s a staple of dystopian science fable — the world split into the privileged few , who exist high above the smog knock in their shiny penthouse , and the downtrodden ragtag and bobtail , who live in the streets below . ordinarily there are sewer mutants too .
And a earth in which fewer and fewer people can yield decent wellness coverage , because insurance is getting more and more expensive and selective , is a big piece of that dystopia . So is a world where people are drive into bankruptcy and lose their dwelling because of ruinous wellness fear expenses . And a universe where health insurance society are make billions in net profit , base on their ability to forfend providing care , is in spades one in which a few favourable people are ascending into the evil penthouses .
In the short term , at least , this natural law will be honest for the insurance policy companies — you ’ll be demand by law to buy health insurance policy from them , after all . Talking to Business Week , Phillip Seligman with Standard & Poors Equity Research says the newfangled law will be a net positive for negociate care establishment because they ’ll gain so many new fellow member , allow for economies of graduated table .
But there ’s at least a comme il faut chance that these telephone exchange , where insurance companies compete to declare oneself the best wad , will ram down prices over time . There ’s alsoa lot of leewayfor the executive of the exchanges to kick out insurers who raise prices or abuse customers , until they doctor their estate car . And even though we did n’t get a “ public option ” where the government competes with those insurance firm , a regulated mart seems like the next good thing — and some observers think it could go to the intro of a public option down the road .
The bank bill also includes some newfangled taxis on high - income Americans that will make some steps towards reducing the disconnection between “ have ” and “ have nots ” — let in higher Medicare payroll department taxes for individuals make more than $ 200,000 per year , excises on super high - end “ Cadillac ” health plans , and businesses that do n’t extend sufficient policy for their employees . These taxes will mostly remove the wealthy Americans , and depending on how you feel about reformist taxation , they ’re either a whole step aside from dystopia or a step towards one .
In any cause , the future dystopia where most people live in the gutter and a few people subsist in the heavens has just suffer a wee morsel less likely .
3 ) corporal serfhood .
It ’s sort of related to , but a common paper in dystopian science fabrication is the world where you belong to to a corporation , body and soul . Think Jennifer Government by Max Barry , where your last name is the name of the troupe you work for . In such a creation , ordinarily , your style option are severely restrain and sometimes the evil company is just send for The Company or The Corporation . The only means out of corporate vassalage is to die . Etc . etc . etc .
And obviously , a world where you ca n’t quit your corporate chore for veneration of losing health insurance is one where you ’re a little second serf - y. This has long been a secret tax on entrepreneurs , since leaving a swelled troupe and come out your own small society has intend pass without health insurance coverage .
And then there ’s the Kafka - esque collective bureaucratism matter . If you ’re like me , you ’ve only had the periodic brush with obstructive government bureaucrats — but frustrative conversations with wellness insurance caller bureaucrats are a unvarying fact of liveliness . The health insurance behemoths spend gazillion of premium dollars paying a small army of people to reckon out way to refuse insurance coverage or make your aliveness more complicated , and it ’s a horrendously ineffective arrangement . you may drop hours on hold , being transferred , filling out push-down storage of forms , getting transferred again , and generally being round - jerked around . It ’s like a put-on of Brazil .
The young law wo n’t completely annihilate this delightful operation , but it ’ll reduce the scope for companies to acquit this way massively . No doubt insurers will still have their own idiosyncratic views of what ’s “ medically necessary , ” but at least they ’ll have a new level lapse in these exchange . And given how much energy the bill spends on measure what forms of care solvent in higher tone upkeep and which are completely useless , we could before long have more actual clinical info with which to argue for treatments that really do make a divergence .
It ’s just a wee step off from a world rule byevil corporations .
https://gizmodo.com/15-evil-corporations-in-science-fiction-5217560
4 ) Our intact economy gets turned over to wellness concern spending , plus mayhap defense team .
This is the one that proceed me up at dark . wellness expenditure , as a percentage of GDP , has been skyrocketing in the U.S. for the past decennary or so , despite a bit of a slowdown . No , seriously . I ’m not pull the leg of . This fearsome chart keeps me lay awake at nighttime sometimes :
( root . )
It goes without saying that this is an unsustainable trend — and if health spending really reached 50 percent of GDP by the midsection of the hundred , we ’d fundamentally all just be working to pay our doctor and infirmary bills . This course affects both the Union government and private employers , both of whom are face with the same problem : keeping people tidy and coping with common diseases is getting more and more expensive all the sentence .
Why has healthcare gotten so expensive ? This is a doubtfulness with no easy answer — if you want a giggle sometime , read themeeting transcriptsof the Medicare Payments Advisory Commission ( an advisory body so toothless , the word “ toothless ” is practically part of its name . ) The most late transcript , for the March confluence , actually start out out with one of the commissioners declare “ my school principal injure . ”
There are many explanations for rocket cost , though : Fancy new engineering save more lives , but they ’re also tremendously expensive . Dr. perform extra tests to cover their asses , or just on the off chance they find something . We have too many specialists and not enough basal care doctors — if you happen to live in a shoes with a spinal sawbones , you ’re a thousand times more likely to have a peculiar character of spinal surgery than if you subsist in the next county over , as a entrancing publishing calledthe Dartmouth Health Atlasillustrates . Health insurance fellowship work heavily to slim their “ aesculapian going ratio ” — the percentage of exchange premium dollar they drop on providing actual care . We do n’t drop enough on bar , and we spend too much on fixing messes we could have prevent . We consume too many Big Macs and smoke too many Camels . And so on , and so on .
So , I hear you asking , is n’t the new wellness maintenance reform nib likely to increase disbursal , what with the Union political science pay for more clobber ?
Hopefully not . The bill includes a lot of cost - cutting measure , some of which could also meliorate the caliber of health care over time . For one affair , the huge giveaway to secret insurers taking part in the Medicare Advantage programme is being scaled back — there ’ll no longer be such huge subsidies to cover patients whom vanilla Medicare would have breed for a circle less . Some of the supervision in those policy substitution may admit ensure insurer are being “ prudent purchasers ” of health care . There ’s alsoa new original computer program on “ bundling,”in which hospitals get a flat payment for ten common circumstance , instead of getting paid separately for each procedure or examination they do . ( Bundling already subsist , to some extent , but this would inflate it somewhat . )
Just have more immature , sound people in the risk of infection pool for insurance may help to bring costs down a routine , because young people will pay premiums without incurring as many costs .
The old “ toothless ” Medicare commission is supplant or affix with a new consistency , the Independent Payment Advisory Board , which would come up with legislative proposal of marriage to scale down Medicare disbursement if it move up faster than a certain target charge per unit by 2013 . The IPAB is n’t allowed to come up with marriage offer that would “ ration guardianship , ” but can find mode to streamline services or melt off overpayments .
The notice also set pressure on doctors to take part in Medicare’squality - measurement program , which has been voluntary up till now — and that could yield more information that permit the government to bring down spending a lot more . People tattle a mickle about “ evidence - base medicine ” as one of the keys to cost - cutting , and it ’s really reliable . We neutralise money because we do n’t have intercourse what works .
As Princeton wellness - aid economic expert Uwe Reinhart tells Ezra Klein , indemnity companies will no longer be spending 40 percent of their premiums on marketing and administration and brokers , thanks to the exchanges . But Reinhart mostly just sees the new police force as a good whole tone towards reduce costs , because it allows us to meet genuine data on health costs and outcomes . “ When McAllen , Texas , became the poster shaver for mellow spending , short the Wall Street Journal jumped out to say that its outgo was rationalise ! The only direction to answer that is to have the really good enquiry to say this is n’t justified . ”
Of course , we do n’t jazz yet if the new practice of law will trim back costs , or whether the cost of guarantee so many more citizenry will actually force back costs up . ( Plus the law does n’t fix Medicare ’s Sustainable maturation Rate organisation , a mechanism which cut doc ’ Medicare payments every class , and that ’s going to be an expensive fix . ) But the expert , including the Congressional Budget Office , are affirmative about deliverance at this item .
5 ) The Fast Food Apocalpyse !
You want scary ? This is scary .
It ’s like Russell T. Davies ’ worst incubus : Millions of people corrode junky food for thought at chain eatery , without let the least inkling what they ’re place in their mouths . But no longer .
As food for thought blogger Marion Nestlepointed out , the new law of nature includes a long - look provision require national calorie judge on menus for any eating house with 20 outlets or more . That means you ’ll have a go at it exactly how many calories your hamburger or salad contains . ( According to the Associated Press , a chain - restaurant Caesar salad has 800 calories , which is sort of alarming . ) And apparently the eating house manufacture actually lobbied for this change , so they would n’t have to deal with deviate state and local laws .
Just having the small calorie counts list simply on every restaurant menu could make mass good for you , in some small fashion .
But it ’s not all good news . There ’s one dystopia that the new jurisprudence puddle more likely :
The Socialist totalistic state
Could the new health care reform law eventually leave to the government taking over the health care industry completely ? Sure , it ’s possible . A lot of citizenry are not so secretly hoping that will befall . We could discover ourselves living in 1984 , or Brazil , or any of a number of other statist dystopia where the government ascertain everything . Although it ’s a bit hard to envision the jump from subsidized health insurance to Room 101 .
But if you want to believe of ways this new scheme could turn dystopian , it ’s not that surd . The governance could use approach to affordable health care to ensure people — already , young people are going to have to yield higher premium than old people . And what if , in a cost - cutting measuring rod , the politics eventually decides that tobacco user must pay higher exchange premium ? Since it ’s their own fault that they ’re at higher risk for pulmonary emphysema and lung cancer . That ’s not in the practice of law now , but it could be add at some stop in the hereafter .
Even if we do n’t get the public option at some point , the jurisprudence certainly gives the government more of a purpose in regulate the wellness insurance industry — for deterrent example , there ’s an “ essential benefits architectural plan ” that specifies exactly what sorting of care , at minimum , your insurance company will have to proffer you .
So yes , this is a definite step towards a world where the government execute the health care industry , and this gives the government functionaries a majuscule degree of ascendancy over your life . You could imagine a futurity where the federal governing uses access to health care as an instrument of social insurance policy — maybe if you criticize President Obama ( or his successor , perhaps ) your Platinum health design might suddenly be downgraded to a Bronze one ? This is n’t something that ’s in the current law — but maybe ( if the Democrats get 70 seats in the Senate and a 100 - vote majority in the House , say ) this could happen .
And of course , if you ’re a dedicated conservativist who does n’t conceive the political science has a use in helping to clear problems like lack of accession to healthcare , and you detest reformist tax and governance programme generally , then it ’s all dystopian . As with most things , it ’s all in your peak of view .
The last major revision to federal health policy , the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 , spawn years of one-year bills pluck and unpick some of its provisions , including the attractively key out Balanced Budget Refinement Act of 1999 . It ’s just like the Balanced Budget Act , only more … neat . peradventure with prissy tea cup , or those little finger sandwich .
- And yes , I have it off that the diseases in those motion picture are in reality cause by medical science . So maybe health care reform will sprain us all into zombi ?
Barack ObamaGawkerHealthMedicine
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and culture news show in your inbox daily .
News from the future , delivered to your nowadays .
